Discover Consumer Reports Replacement Windows Ratings


You Are Here » Home » Window Reviews » Consumer Reports

Consumer Reports Window Ratings

See consumer reports window ratings for popular brands and models. Find additional recommended models as well as our picks for the best replacement windows on the market. The prices below are for the window itself and don't include the cost of installation.

Consumer Reports Wood Clad Windows

Model: Marvin Clad Ultimate

Price: $400
Rating: 88
See more Marvin windows prices.

Model: Marvin Wood Ultrex Integrity

Price: $315
Rating: 87
Marvin Integrity Pricing

Model: Andersen 400 Tilt-Wash

Price: $350
Rating: 85
Explore Andersen window costs.

Model: Pella ProLine

Price: $215
Rating: 82
More on Pella prices.

Model: Andersen 200 Series Tilt-Wash

Price: $235
Rating: 80
See additional Andersen windows reviews.

Model: Pella Designer Series Precision Fit

Price: $600
Rating: 79
Find additional reviews of Pella windows.

Model: Crestline Select Clad

Price: $340
Rating: 66
More on Crestline window costs.

Model: Weather Shield Custom Shield

Price: $395
Rating: 56
Browse Weathershield consumer reviews.

Model: JELD-WEN Premium Wood Tradition Plus

Price: $360
Rating: 50
See more Jeld Wen pricing.

Consumer Reports Vinyl Windows

Model: Survivor Reliabilt 5600

Price: $180
Rating: 73
Read consumer reviews of Reliabilt windows.

Model: Alside UltraMaxx Replacement

Price: $395
Rating: 70
Find additional Alside prices.

Model: American Craftsman 9500

Price: $220
Rating: 69
Explore American Craftsman costs and pricing.

Model: CertainTeed Bryn Mawr II

Price: $250
Rating: 63
Find homeowner Certainteed review information.

Model: CertainTeed New Castle XT

Price: $250
Rating: 63
Read all of our MI windows reviews.

Model: Crestline CrestFit Vinyl

Price: $255
Rating: 61

Model: Pella ThermaStar

Price: $215
Rating: 44

Editor's Choice: Soft-Lite Elements LS

Price: $415
Read all of our Soft-Lite windows prices.

Consumer Reports Fiberglass Windows

Model: Pella Impervia

Price: $255
Rating: 87
Additional best fiberglass windows.

Editor's Choice: Marvin Infinity

Price: $365
Read all of our Marvin product reviews.

Frame Material
Window Style
Overall Grade Of Window
Installation Type
How Many Windows
Zip Code

Private Policy